Selected Quora Answers

How would the Wright Brothers get funding from VCs?

September 6, 2016

The Wright brothers did get funding from a venture capitalist, Charles Ranlett Flint’s merchant banking house Flint & Co. Flint is better known for his roll-ups, including merging four companies into the Computing-Tabulating-Recording Company (better known by the name it took a few years later: IBM), U.S. Rubber, and the chewing gum conglomerate American Chicle (now part of Cadbury as Cadbury Adams, makers of Bubblicious, Dentyne, and Halls cough drops.)

The relationship was somewhat different than VC relationships today, including financially. But Flint partner Hart Berg was very active trying to negotiate deals with European governments to buy Wright airplanes. In other ways it was clearly recognizable: Orville complained to Wilbur in a 1907 letter that Flint “have been so tricky that it keeps us busy watching them”, a sentiment many modern entrepreneurs have expressed about VCs.

Of course, the Wright brothers were great inventors but awful entrepreneurs. Even though they had filed patents that covered altering the shape of the wings to effect turns (the key thing that previous inventors had missed) they were paranoid about their designs being stolen. Skeptical buyers demanded to see a test flight before they would commit to purchasing, but the Wrights for years refused this demand (they even refused to demonstrate for Flint, but Flint went ahead with a relationship anyway.) It was only after others, including a consortium funded by Alexander Graham Bell that included the genius engine designer Glenn Curtiss, began to catch up that they allowed anyone to see them fly. Sales quickly followed. But Curtiss and others, including the Frenchman Bleriot, were poised to compete. If the Wrights had clinched a sale earlier, they could have seized the market and the history of the aviation business would be very different.

Why do things exist? Why is there not absolute nothingness?

December 8, 2014

Two monks were arguing about a flag. One said: “The flag is moving.”

The other said: “The wind is moving.”

The sixth patriarch happened to be passing by. He told them: “Not the wind, not the flag; mind is moving.”

Mumon’s comment:
The sixth patriarch said: “The wind is not moving, the flag is not moving. Mind is moving.” What did he mean? If you understand this intimately, you will see the two monks there trying to buy iron and gaining gold. The sixth patriarch could not bear to see those two dull heads, so he made such a bargain.

Wind, flag, mind moves,
The same understanding.
When the mouth opens
All are wrong.

What happens to the capital structure of a company after two firms merge?

October 24, 2014

Even in a merger, one of the firms is almost always the legal acquiror. Calling it a merger rather than an acquisition is usually an acknowledgement that the resulting company is on a more equal footing.

The acquiring company issues new stock in the merger. So, say Company A and Company B are merging and A is the technical acquiror. A has 1,000,000 shares outstanding and B has 200,000 shares outstanding. The merger is 50/50. In this case A would issue 1,000,000 new shares to the shareholders of B: each share of B would be replaced with 5 shares of A. A would now have 2,000,000 shares, so someone who owned 10% of A before the merger would own 5% of the post-merger company.

A can also change its name, its executive team, its board, and pretty much anything else in the course of the merger. But, then, it could have done that at any time.

What are red flags when choosing an angel investor?

March 29, 2014

The only time you should trust your gut is when ordering in a restaurant.

You don’t need to like your angel investors, but you do need to believe that they will be helpful, and not unhelpful. Helpful means they are bringing something to the party besides money: connections, advice, expertise, coinvestors, something. Not unhelpful means they understand what the life-cycle of a startup looks like, so they won’t be calling you every week asking for audited financials, out in the world representing themselves as a decision-maker for your company, being unprofessional when you’re raising your next round, etc. (You owe some accountability to your investors, but this needs to be balanced against your limited time and angels need to help you do that by not being overly demanding.)

You can find out whether an angel will be helpful and not unhelpful in only one way: ask the founders of their other portfolio companies. Your gut doesn’t mean anything, that’s just what you believe. Why trust belief when the facts are a phone call away? I wouldn’t even bother asking the angel, just email one of their other founders, let them know the conversation is just between the two of you, and ask about their experience with the angel. Then do it three more times. It’s a couple hours of your time, and can save you the scores of hours that dealing with a bad angel can take.

What exactly does it mean for a startup to raise X dollars at a valuation of Y?

March 27, 2014

First, the technical answer. When someone says they raised $X at a valuation of $Y… let’s put that into more precise terms. Venture investors–who usually buy shares of stock from the company, not from another investor–call the nominal value of the company before they invest the pre-money valuation. If they then invest money into the company–the company gets the money and issues new shares, a primary offering–the company is then worth the pre-money plus the amount invested, called the post-money valuation.

Think of it this way. You own a bag made of gold thread, worth $1 million dollars. I put $500,000 of cash into the bag. Before I put the money in–the pre-money–the bag is worth $1 million. After I put the money in–the post-money–the full bag is worth $1,500,000. If we were to fairly agree how much of the full bag we each own, I would own 1/3 and you would own 2/3, since that’s the relative value we contributed.

Now imagine the bag is not actually made of $1 million worth of gold, it’s just a really old and beautiful bag from ancient Greece that a museum would pay $1 million for. So it doesn’t have an intrinsic value of $1 million, that’s just what you could sell it for. The pre- and post-moneys would be the same, right?

Now imagine that you found the bag in an attic and have no idea what the price is. But you know for 100% certainty that if you had $500,000 to have a TV show made and aired tomorrow about how awesome the bag is, that you could sell the bag for $1 million tomorrow. I agree that there is a 100% certainty that this will happen. The pre- and post-moneys are still the same, and if I put in the $500,000 and you put in the bag, then we would still own 1/3, 2/3, right?

Now comes the tricky part. What if you had a 50% certainty that the bag would be worth $2 million after the $500,000 TV show? What if you had a 20% certainty it would be worth $5 million? What if you had a 20% certainty that it would be worth $10 million after eight years? (Because money today is worth more than money eight years from now, all else being equal.) What if you had a notion that if everything went your way for ten years, and that you might have to raise some more money in the interim, that there is a small but indefinable chance that your app, er… bag, would be worth $1 billion?

Anyway, to answer your question: when someone says they got an investment of $X at $Y valuation, $X is the money into the bag and $Y is either the pre-money or post-money valuation of the bag itself (you can’t tell which from that answer itself, you’d have to ask them to be more precise.) But this valuation isn’t actually the “value” of the company, it’s a guess by both sides as to the valuation that will make the investor a risk and time adjusted fair rate of return.

What’s the best valuation method to use for seed rounds in tech startups?

February 9, 2014

I don’t like the grading method of valuing companies. Either you believe the market is big and the solution makes sense and the team can execute or you don’t. There’s no point in saying “hey, that’s a weak team, so take 30% off the pre-money.” Only invest in good teams. If they aren’t, then give them some advice on how to become one. Only invest in good ideas. If it isn’t one, tell the team and tell them why. Doing otherwise is a disservice to them. Investing in a team or idea that still needs some work is wasting their time.

If I believe the team, market, idea, then here’s how I value a company:
1. Estimate how much the company can exit for if it is successful;
2. Estimate how long it will take to get there;
3. Estimate the probability of the company being successful;
4. Figure out how much dilution I will take between seed and exit;
5. Multiply 1, 3 and 4 together and take the present value of that number for the period of time in 2 at 30% per year;
6. Divide that number in half because I’m an incurable optimist.

Voila, post-money valution.

This method is subjective. So:
– Know their market; and
– Know what companies in that market exit for.

Step back at the end and see if the valuation is reasonable. If it seems out-of-whack, ask yourself why you think that. Examine your assumptions! If it is pretty far from market, ask yourself why your assumptions are so different than every other investor’s. Is it because you are so much smarter than everyone else? Think again.

If the valuation seems low (below, say $2 million pre-money) and the company is going to require more money after the seed, ask yourself when the management owns less of the company than they would receive if they went and got a job at some other startup. If that comes to pass any time before exit, you probably don’t want to do the deal.

Is it possible to short Venture Capital funds?

November 21, 2013

Yes: start a company, pay yourself an enormous salary, bankrupt company.

If an investor asks for their equity not to be diluted when we raise another round in the future, what does this mean and is it a good idea for founders?

October 7, 2013

This is crazy. DO NOT DO IT.

As an investor, I work to align my interests with those of the management of the company. That way I know that the people who are doing the work will benefit my ownership in the same way they benefit their own. The management will not make decisions that hurt me, because they would be hurting themselves. No smart investor would set things up so that what benefits them hurts management. I can imagine a hundred scenarios where that would end up badly for everyone, where it would make more sense for the entrepreneurs to walk away than to continue.

Future investors care that you–the entrepreneur–is motivated to continue building the business. They will not want you doubly diluted because some greedhead gave you a bit of money a few years ago. No sensible investor would follow-on into a company that has this kind of deal. I once worked with a founder that had given fixed percentages of his company away; when I added them all up, he had promised 105% of the company to various people. I was not impressed.

Align your investors’ interests with your own*, there is no better guarantee of success for everyone. This is not a zero-sum game. If you can’t, then you need to improve your product or business plan until you can.

—–
* At least in the upside case. Investors will almost always have a better deal than you in the downside case, for various reasons.

How does one become a successful venture capitalist if they already have money to invest?

September 10, 2013

I asked this question of a veteran venture capitalist twenty-five years ago. He said “First you start a company and work like hell to grow it as fast as you can, make it a leader in its industry. Take it public and run the public company for five years. Then you’re about 50 and have made some money and have a ton of industry and personal contacts, you understand the life-cycle of a business, how to grow and manage it. Then you retire and go into venture capital. Really, before that what do you have to offer the founders you invest in?”

I teach a class on entrepreneurship at Columbia’s engineering school. One semester Chris Dixon came in to guest lecture. One of the students asked him this question. (Chris’ first job out of business school was at Bessemer Venture Partners.) Chris said that when he was a second year at Harvard Business School there were about five jobs open in the VC industry–none of them as investors, mind you, and none of them partner track, since none of them are–and about 600 of the 900 people he was graduating with applied to them. These are not good odds.

There are about about 5,000 venture capital investors in the US (I took that number from the NVCA’s yearbook, but it’s from memory). There are more than 8,000 undergraduates at Columbia. That drove home to my students how few jobs there are in the industry. It’s hard to get a job at Google, right? There are more than 50,000 Google employees, ten times as many as VCs.

So the short answer is, you don’t.

But, of course, people do. The main paths into VC are: founder (many examples), executive at a fast-growth company in a key industry (John Doerr, for instance), banker, lawyer, and journalist (Michael Moritz, for example). Very few investing partners worked their way up from an entry level job in VC; on the east coast Fred Wilson is the only one I can think of. Really, everybody has a different path. Check my venture capital firm genealogy (@http://neuvc.com/labs/vcgenealogy), it shows where the founders of the firms came from if you zoom in.

The better question to ask is, if you were a venture capitalist what would you have to offer the people you invest in that’s so valuable? Anybody can pick companies and hand them money (not that it’s easy to do even that right) but if you want to be good at the job, you need to be able to offer them more than that. If you can, then VCs might be interested in hiring you. But be honest with yourself, everybody’s smart and well-educated and worked for a startup. Did you have deep experience, through good times and bad, in a cutting-edge field learning things that nobody else knows? Do other startup folk seek you out for your advice and defer to your opinions on certain topics? When startup folk you don’t know ask themselves “who would I most like to discuss my idea with” are you one of the top five in their minds?

Also, keep in mind though that joining an existing partnership is about chemistry just as much as ability. Partnerships are like marriages, except more so: you spend more time together, you need to reach consensus more, and the financial entanglements that persist if you break it off are more complicated. People go into partnership not only with people who will do great work, but with people they think they can get along with long-term. For most people, you don’t find that very often. This is one reason many of the best venture investors decide to start their own firms rather than join existing ones. When Wilson left Flatiron Ventures, you would think some established firm would have scooped him up. Instead he decided to start his own firm. This is common. (I’m not saying Fred’s not easy to get along with, I just mean that you can’t know and that’s a huge risk.)

So the long answer is: if you want the job, the best way to get it is to go out and start doing it. If you’re good at it then either someone will notice or you can go raise money and start your own.

What do active investors think about Adeo Ressi’s convertible equity term sheet?

September 1, 2012

Let’s be clear: convertible debt in a seed-stage startup *is* equity. Not equity in the legal sense, but equity in the sense that the investor is only entitled to whatever is left over after everyone else is paid–this is the underlying definition of equity.

There is one and only one reason for a professional investor to invest using convertible debt: it is cheap. When I invested in Simple (nee BankSimple) paying lawyers to write docs would have eaten a not insubstantial portion of my investment. So I pulled a convertible debt document off my laptop, filled in the blanks, and handed it over with a check. The company was either going to work or it was not. Simple did. With another company where I did the same thing, it did not. The founder, when he realized that his idea was not going to work, handed me back two-thirds of my seed investment (because he was a standup guy; that money is earmarked for his next startup.) Any legal fees would have been dead-weight loss to me.

There are some good things about convertible equity but the declared big deal about it–that there is no repayment date–makes no sense to me.

I had this discussion with an entrepreneur when he saw the 18-month term on the convertible note we were negotiating:

Entrepreneur: “Can we make this date like five years from now?”
Me: “You told me you would need to raise more money within a year.”
E: “We will, but what if we go longer?”
Me: “If you’ve gone that long and not been able to raise your A, then it’s not working and we should talk about it.”
E: “But what if you just call the debt and put the company into bankruptcy?”
Me: “Why in god’s name would I do that? What would I get, your source code? What am I going to do with a bunch of source and none of the people who wrote it? I’d be destroying any value that remained if I put you out of business.”
E: “Then why have a term at all?”
Me: “Because if you’re failing I want you to have to sit down with me and figure out what to do next.”

That’s one reason to have a term: because if things aren’t working out, the entrepreneur and I have to talk. This is what should happen anyway, and if you don’t trust your lead investor (or whatever combination of investors that control calling the notes) to have a reasonable discussion with you at that point, you need different investors. And if you can’t find reasonable investors it’s all going to go badly for you anyway, so it doesn’t matter what kind of contract you sign.

And then there’s a side note for the angel investors out there.

Back in the day when VCs had a bit more market leverage and so tried to cover their edge cases in some reasonable way, we had a thing called a redemption right. This clause gave you the ability to ask for your money back after some period of time, usually three to five years. There was really only one use for this clause (aside from bad VC or entrepreneur behavior): if the company was going sideways you still had a path to exit.

I used this once. A company I invested in in January 2000 lost 80% of its revenue and all of its growth prospects when the dot-com bubble burst. Through some deft management, the company survived and became a steady earner. But it never again earned enough to be an exit candidate at anywhere close to the post-money of the round I lead. This was a quandary: the company was worth more than the money invested but less than the bubble-era valuation. The founder left and the company was being run by people who were working for a salary, not equity. The company still runs today and is still (AFAIK) a steady but quiet earner. If I did not have a redemption right, I would still have equity in that company today, and I would have that same equity the day I die, because it would NEVER EXIT. But because I had a redemption right, I got my money back and the company went happily on.

There is a corollary in convertible equity: what if the company you invest in starts making a little bit of money and never raises more money? You now own a piece of something that is intrinsically valuable, but that piece is worthless to you because it never throws off cash. What now? Convertible debt gives you the not-so-very-great-but-at-least-it’s-something option of getting your money back and moving on. Convertible equity does not. This seems like a reasonable thing to me.

That said, edge cases are edge cases, and if the convertible equity terms were reasonable enough–with redemption rights and a valuation cap–and getting the docs done was equally inexpensive (something I have some real doubts about but am willing to be convinced on) then it’s fine. But then why not just do a priced round?

Who are the most legendary individual VCs of all time?

December 23, 2011

Hands down, Arthur Rock. He organized the round into Fairchild, the granddaddy of all VC investments and arguably the first VC seed investment: the Fairchild round was essentially an investment in nothing but a team. Also, through Davis and Rock and Arthur Rock and Associates, invested in Teledyne, Scientific Data Systems, Intel and Apple. In fact, when Intel was funded, Moore and Noyce made Rock chairman of the board.

Tommy Davis Jr. left Davis and Rock to start Mayfield. Dick Kramlich left Arthur Rock and Associates to start NEA. If by legendary you mean more than the highest return on invested capital, but also genius, creativity and influence, then Rock is it.

What are the most significant VC investments of all time?

December 23, 2011

Some to start:

  • Continental Cablevision; 1966; Greylock
  • Intel; 1968; Venrock, Davis and Rock
  • Apple; 1978; Sequoia, Venrock, Matrix, Brentwood
  • Genentech; 1976; Kleiner Perkins
  • Google; 1999; Kleiner Perkins, Sequoia
  • Office Depot; ?; Crosspoint Venture Partners
  • Microsoft; 1981; Technology Venture Investors
  • DEC; 1957; American Research and Development
  • Amdahl; 1971; Heizer Corp.
  • Federal Express; 1973; Heizer Corp.
  • National Semiconductor; 1967; Electronics Capital Corp.

How much money do founders take home, on average, compared to VCs?

December 11, 2011

As a first-order, assumption-laden, top-down approximation… if $100 is invested in startups:

  • Historical VC returns are ~20%/year;
  • A representative startup is about 5 years from funding to exit/failure;
  • In 5 years, $100 at 20% p.a. turns into ~$250;
  • The VC keeps 20% of the upside: 20% * ($250-$100) = $30;
  • Founders own ~20% at exit, so they walk away with $50;
  • The VCs’ funders–the LPs–keep the remainder.


Note that when I say ‘VC’ and “Founders’, I mean in aggregate. In reality, there are more founders than VCs, so on an individual basis this number is different. Also, I think that the distribution of this money is vastly different for VCs and Founders–VCs have a lower beta.

How much venture capital did Apple Computer initially raise?

May 19, 2011

Different sources give wildly different, and conflicting, versions of what happened. As near I can tell:

Mike Markulla put in $250k as an angel–$80k as equity (or $92k in one account) and $170k as a loan–in 1976 or 1977. At least one account has Arthur Rock also putting money in at this time

Apple then raised $518,000 in January 1978, $704,000 in September 1978 and $2.3 million in December 1980. The company was taken public on December 22, 1980 by Hambrecht & Quist, represented by Wilson Sonsini. I believe the venture investors included Sequoia (Don Valentine) and Matrix Partners.

More definitive information could be found in Apple’s IPO documents, their prospectus. The SEC does not have digital versions of these available until 1994, so Apple’s does not seem to be online anywhere. There is a copy in the Stanford library, though:

http://findingaids.stanford.edu/xtf/view?docId=ead/mss/m1007.xml;chunk.id=c02-1.8.6.2.7;brand=default

Anyone there want to dig them up (both the preliminary, Box 2 Folder 17, and the final, Box 2 Folder 18), scan them and put them online?
—–
Edit, 3/29/2012.

John Wilson’s excellent “The New Venturers” (out of print) had this to say:

After Markulla invested, the company went out seeking venture capital. The first outside round sought $500,000 for 15% of the company (a $3 million pre-money, expensive for the time.) Venrock put up $288,000; Sequoia put up $100,000, Arthur Rock made a small personal investment; and Andrew Grove–the COO of Intel–also invested.

Wilson also notes that Henry Singleton of Teledyne invested $100,000 in 1978. This implies that the 1978 financing was:
Venrock: $288,000
Sequoia: 100,000
Singleton: 100,000
Groves + Rock: 30,000

“Later rounds of financing brought Apple an additional $7 million, to which Venrock contributed $200,000, and its initial public offering in December 1980 raised $101 million, including $12 million for some late-round venture investors.”

Is Buddhism a religion or philosophy?

March 23, 2011

Buddhism is a religion. First I’ll show you why. Then I’ll show you why I am wrong.

1. What is popularly thought of as Buddhism in the United States is not representative of Buddhism in the world at all. Much of Mahayana Buddhism is religious. For example, Pure Land Buddhism–a Japanese branch of Mahayana–has many parallels to the theistic religions. Pure Land is centered around Amhitaba, who has trans-human power and resides in a pure Buddha-field, where his followers after they die reside free of the cycle of rebirth (but short of Nirvana.) Some followers of Pure Land believe that reincarnation into the Pure Land requires little more than belief in Amhitaba. If you are asking the question of whether Buddhism is a religion, you are probably not familiar with Mahayana, the most popular branch of Buddhism in the world.

There has been Buddhism in the United States since at least 1898, when two Japanese Buddhist priests of the Jodo Shinshu school arrived in San Francisco. Despite shrinking due to anti-Japanese prejudice during World War II and Japanese-American assimilation into American culture, this sect has remained the most popular of the American Buddhist religions. But after World War II and especially in the 1960s, a form of Zen Buddhism began to gain adherents, primarily among non-Asians. This form was, in a sense, non-religious, as articulated by Daisetz Suzuki, one of its chief popularizers, in “An Introduction to Zen Buddhism”:

Zen has no God to worship, no ceremonial rites to observe, no future abode to which the dead are destined, and … no soul whose welfare is to be looked after by somebody else and whose immortality is a matter of intense concern.

(HT: Sydney Ahlstrom’s “A Religious History of the American People”.)

Many American practitioners of Buddhism believe in something that might be best called “primitive” Buddhism, a core set of beliefs that are as confined to what the Buddha himself reportedly said as can be reasonably accommodated as a coherent system. These beliefs are common to almost all branches of Buddhism and are articulated in many popular books (my favorite is Thich Nhat Hanh’s “The Heart of the Buddha’s Teachings”) and whether this subset of beliefs is a philosophy or religion is probably what this question is actually asking.

But keep in mind that this minimum viable subset of Buddhist belief relates to the traditional Buddhist religions much like the actual words of Jesus relate to Christianity: they are sacred and universally believed, but in practice and belief are only a small part of such elaborately articulated religions as Catholicism. This elaboration is, of course, an almost universal pattern in religious development. Many of the popularizers of Buddhism to the West are teaching what they think newcomers can accept, believing that acceptance of some belief is better than rejection of all. This particularly makes sense in a religion like Buddhism, where learning takes place gradually over many, many lifetimes.

2. Religion and philosophy share many concerns.

Buddhism, even in its “primitive” form, shares almost all of the concerns of a religion, and very little of the sole concerns of philosophy. Buddhism clearly defines an eschatology, a soteriology and a mythology (note: mythology in this context means ‘sacred narrative’, not ‘made-up story.’) Whether or not ‘primitive’ Buddhism has a pneumatology is arguable; Mahayana certainly does. (Also note, I am using pneumatology as a catch-all for beliefs about divine beings and human interaction with them, not merely in the more common Christian sense. Perhaps there is a better word.)

3. But, in the end, Buddhism puts the question of whether it is a philosophy or religion right back at you. Start with a definition of the goals of philosophy. Mark Siderits, in “Buddhism as Philosophy” says:

What sets philosophy apart as a discipline is more its concern with how to answer questions than the answers themselves. To study philosophy is to learn to think carefully and critically about complex issues. It is not necessarily to learn the ‘answers’ that the discipline has arrived at.

This makes the question of whether Buddhism is a religion more complex. Buddhism does not ask you to accept its core principles on faith, it does not ask you to simply believe the results of someone else’s gnosis.

The famous story of the Buddha’s visit to the Kalamas (http://www.buddhanet.net/e-learning/kalama1.htm) :

The Kalamas who were inhabitants of Kesaputta sitting on one side said to the Blessed One: “There are some monks and brahmins, venerable sir, who visit Kesaputta. They expound and explain only their own doctrines; the doctrines of others they despise, revile, and pull to pieces. Some other monks and brahmins too, venerable sir, come to Kesaputta. They also expound and explain only their own doctrines; the doctrines of others they despise, revile, and pull to pieces. Venerable sir, there is doubt, there is uncertainty in us concerning them. Which of these reverend monks and brahmins spoke the truth and which falsehood?”

“It is proper for you, Kalamas, to doubt, to be uncertain; uncertainty has arisen in you about what is doubtful. Come, Kalamas. Do not go upon what has been acquired by repeated hearing; nor upon tradition; nor upon rumor; nor upon what is in a scripture; nor upon surmise; nor upon an axiom; nor upon specious reasoning; nor upon a bias towards a notion that has been pondered over; nor upon another’s seeming ability; nor upon the consideration, ‘The monk is our teacher.’ Kalamas, when you yourselves know: ‘These things are bad; these things are blamable; these things are censured by the wise; undertaken and observed, these things lead to harm and ill,’ abandon them.

In other words, the Buddha does not want you to believe, he wants you to seek out the truth–the very essence of philosophical enquiry. Over the course of thousands of lives, you will have the opportunity to believe many things and your experience will be a guide to which are correct and which are not. The Buddha was confident that in the course of your existence you would engage in experimental philosophy, eventually ending up discovering the truth, as he himself did.

What was NYC’s second-biggest tech startup exit?

March 18, 2011

It depends on what you mean by exit. My firm was the early-stage backer of Razorfish, and we exited in early 2000 when the market cap was pretty high. When they sold to SBI, though, it was for much less.

On the other hand, Doubleclick’s sale to Google wasn’t an exit: they had previously been acquired out of the public markets by investment firm Hellman & Friedman–either the IPO or the sale to H&F was the ‘exit’ for the venture backers, depending on when they sold, but almost certainly not the sale to Google… that was H&F’s exit.

Some New York based tech startups and their peak values and/or sale prices:

DoubleClick: $12 billion (peak market cap)
Razorfish: $6 billion (peak market cap)
Agency.com: $3 billion (peak market cap)
DoubleClick: $1.1 billion (sale to Hellman & Friedman)
24/7 Real Media: $1 billion (peak market cap)
TheStreet.com: $1 billion (peak market cap)
Right Media: $850 million (sale to Yahoo!)
TheGlobe.com: $840 million (peak market cap)
About.com: $690 million (sale to Primedia)
24/7 Real Media: $649 million (sale to WPP)
LinkShare: $425 million (sale to Rakuten)
Huffington Post: $315 million (sale to AOL)
Quigo: $300 million (sale to AOL)
Tacoda: $275 million (sale to AOL)

I don’t have numbers for Medscape, but it was up there.

I know I’m missing some big and obvious ones here, but can’t think of how to make an authoritative list. If I think of more, I’ll add them.

How would you go about “shorting” a startup?

January 29, 2011

Start a competitor. Sell shares

I have a successful product, should I ask for preferred shares when raising my first VC round?

January 22, 2011

There are several ways to think about why VCs insist on getting preferred stock:

1) Information Asymmetry.

You’re out raising money, telling VCs about the customers who love your product, who are about to become customers “as soon as the contracts clear their legal department”, etc. You raise $2mm on a $6mm pre. Six months later the product still doesn’t work and the customers never signed. You’re approached with an offer to buy your IP for $1mm, and that turns out to be your best option. If there’s no preference, you walk away with $750k and the VC gets $250k–a $750k loss. This seems unfair to the VC: you have a gain and they have a loss, even though what you told them was wrong. The VC could have done more due diligence to prevent this, but that’s not really the most efficient solution. A preference gives the VC more room to trust you and your predictions and not spend a huge amount of time and money on due diligence. It allows them to fund riskier ventures more quickly.

2) Fund IRR.

If two or three out of every ten investments in a VC fund do well and two or three fail outright, then there are four to six that go sideways, more or less. The difference between getting their money back whole and getting just a fraction of their money back can mean a 10% swing on a fund’s cash on cash return. This can easily be the difference between one quintile and the next, and that can make all the difference in raising their next fund.

3) Signaling.

If you believe there’s a good chance you’re going to go sideways or are overly calculating about your downside risk, maybe you should be a VC, not an entrepreneur. Confidence is a key factor in entrepreneurial success.

Unless the cash you have in the bank is a really large part of the value of the company (in which case I suggest you not raise venture money at all, but just keep running the business and generating cash) then I don’t think asking for preferred makes sense. The reasons VCs want preferred really don’t apply to you (1 and 3) or send the wrong signal (2 vs. 3).

Is a DCF (discounted cash flows) valuation pre-money or post-money?

January 7, 2011

Even though it is unusual to value a startup with a DCF, it can be (and is, in some cramped analyst’s cubicle somewhere) done.

If you need the money to execute the plan where the cash-flows are being generated, then you have to assume the business being evaluated already has the cash, so the answer is post-money.

What are predictions for Apple’s iAd initiative?

December 28, 2010

I predict that Apple will find itself unhappy with its iAd initiative. iAds are classic Apple: they are beautiful and new and are performing well. Apple makes sure of this by controlling the process to a level unprecedented in recent ad agency history, and charging a high price for it. But a command-and-control environment is inimical to advertising creative, and a high agency margin cuts into performance.

Apple’s need to control the creative has been causing discontent at their clients both because Apple and the client may disagree with what needs to be done and because Apple has become an operational bottleneck. Apple’s need to control creative to maintain high quality standards is great for now, because the quality of online ads has been relatively low; Apple showing the ad world how to make really high-quality ads sets an example for everyone else.

But one of the reasons the ad agency world is fragmented is that good ideas can pop up anywhere. There aren’t many ad campaigns that really change the game for a particular brand, but when they come up, they are priceless. The chances that Apple will come up with one are pretty low: any really good creative would prefer to be the top person at an agency than a second-class citizen at Apple, and good ideas are people-driven. Not having breakout ideas may not matter now, when simply making higher quality ads (as opposed to having better ideas) makes a bigger difference, but as the sector matures ideas will matter more and Apple won’t have them.

The performance piece will be what kills the business for Apple though. Ad agencies don’t have great margins. An agency with a 10% net income margin would be doing really well (and that margin is off of *net* revenue–i.e., after the cost of buying the media itself is removed from the equation.) Apple’s net income/gross profit margin is 55%. This may currently be apples to oranges (sorry!) because Apple is charging a much higher commission than an agency can: some 40% to an agency’s 5% or less. But therein lies the problem: the extra 35% directly impacts performance (as measured by ROI.) If a traditional agency charges 5% and Apple charges 40%, the ads must perform more than 50% better to have a comparable ROI. This may be possible now, when Apple’s high quality level is so novel, but when others copy it, the margin differential will have to shrink.

Over time, as customers continue to be discontented and Apple finds that running an ad agency is inherently less stable and profitable than running a hardware and software company, the iAd product will be deemphasized and, eventually, spun off or discontinued.

[note: iAd was discontinued in 2016.]

Will traditional ad agencies die the same ‘death’ as major record labels?

December 6, 2010

While ad agencies have stepped in to take ancillary revenue when it’s available (as in media buying), their traditional and core function–determining how to get people to respond to products and brands–remains a creative endeavor.

The one consistent theme in advertising over the years has been the difficulty of breaking out of the clutter. To be effective, ads need to get their audience to pay attention. But they can’t do so by being shocking, it’s a fine line. The best creative folk can come up with communication that is simultaneously against-the-grain and of-the-times. The Apple iPod commercials, for instance.If you’re not a critical media watcher, you should rent Art & Copy, a documentary about ads over the years, it puts the ads that now seem mundane–”Where’s the Beef?”–in their contemporary context.

Some agency activities–especially technology-driven ones like media buying–will change, with the value created accruing to technology firms and the agencies simply using those tools for their clients. But the core client-service piece will remain.

Agencies are clueless in the short-term. They always have been. Because of this the death of the agency has been widely predicted for at least 20 years (probably longer, probably as long as there have been agencies.) But agencies are good at adapting to change in the medium-term (often by buying the upstarts.) They survive and have survived because they are key to the creative process that is at the core of their clients’ connection to consumers.

If an angel or VC is already invested in a potential competitor, is it advisable to avoid talking to that investor?

November 5, 2010

I think it is advisable to talk to that investor. They have valuable insight into the marketplace.

Most investors won’t invest in competing companies, so best to keep the conversation general: don’t ask about the confidential details of your competitor (they won’t tell you) and don’t tell them your confidential details. (If what you consider confidential includes the very idea of your company, though, the conversation might be very short.)

Generally, I believe that in quickly growing industries, the main competition is not between various startups but between the startups and whatever incumbents they are disrupting. If this is the case for you, then you should be talking to your ‘competitors’ all the time. Every time they pitch a potential customer, every time they get a favorable mention from the press, every time they make a key hire, they are helping you by building your market.